The Worst Audi S4 Years to Avoid Vs Best / Reliable Used S4 Models

Patrick Oziegbe
Updated On:

If you’re in the market for a luxury car, the Audi S4 might be on your radar. However, not all model years are created equal regarding reliability.

To help you make an informed decision when purchasing a used Audi S4, knowing which years to avoid is essential.

The performance-oriented Audi S4 has several generations available for used car shoppers to consider.
Identifying the best and worst years for the vehicle can significantly impact its longevity and your overall satisfaction with the car.

Audi S4 Years to Avoid

Audi S4 Years to Avoid

As you look into purchasing an Audi S4, you must know which model years to avoid due to potential issues or common complaints.

This section focuses on the 2008, 2012, 2013, and 2014 model years.

2008 Model Year

The 2008 Audi S4 might be the oldest model in this list, but it’s worth mentioning due to certain issues.

Some of the common problems reported by owners during this year were related to the engine, transmission, and excessive oil consumption. These issues can lead to costly maintenance or repairs down the line.

2012 Model Year

While the 2012 Audi S4 has been cited as one of the more reliable S4 models, it is still crucial to proceed with caution when considering purchasing a used one.

Some owners have reported issues with the timing chain tensioners, which could cause significant engine damage if not addressed.

Additionally, there have been reports of excessive oil consumption, which might require frequent top-ups and monitoring.

2013 Model Year

The 2013 model year for the Audi S4 saw an increase in reported complaints, particularly with the vehicle’s electrical system and engine.

Some of the common issues included malfunctioning sensors, navigation system glitches, and problems with the fuel system.

Make sure to thoroughly inspect the vehicle’s electronics before purchasing to prevent future headaches.

2014 Model Year

As for the 2014 Audi S4, the main concerns revolved around the engine and cooling system.

Some owners experience water pump failures and thermostat issues, which can lead to overheating and further engine damage.

Be cautious when considering this model year and ensure that all necessary maintenance and repairs have been conducted to keep your vehicle in optimal condition.

When shopping for an Audi S4, thoroughly research and assess any potential model years to avoid unwanted problems with used vehicles.

Reliability and Common Issues

Engine Problems

The Audi S4 has had reports of engine problems, particularly issues with the timing chain and chain tensioners.

Staying vigilant about these components is crucial as they can lead to expensive repairs. Remember that not all years are created equal, so researching the specific S4 model you’re interested in can save you some potential headaches in the long run.

Transmission Issues

Transmission issues have also been reported in some S4 models. When considering a used S4, double-check its history and maintenance records to ensure the transmission is in good shape.

The reliability of the Audi S4 can vary greatly from year to year, but utilizing a reliable source like RepairPal and its reliability rating system can help you choose a more dependable vehicle.

Conducting thorough research before purchasing your S4 will make all the difference in your driving experience and overall satisfaction.

What are The Best S4 Years to Buy?

According to various sources, the 2012 Audi S4 is often considered the most reliable and best year to buy due to its dependability, safety, affordability, and resale value.

The 2012 model boasts a balance of performance and features, making it an excellent choice for those purchasing a used Audi S4.

Another great option to consider is the 2014 Audi S4. This model year is part of the B8.5 generation, which has an updated DSG transmission that tends to be more reliable than the older B8 models.

The 2014 S4 also features a modern design and improved performance compared to previous years.

Lastly, it’s worth looking at the 2016 Audi S4. As the final year of the B8.5 generation, this model has all the refinements and updates from the previous years.

It’s a powerful and stylish choice with reliability and top-notch features, making it another solid pick when buying a used Audi S4.

Performance and Features

Power and Horsepower

When looking at the Audi S4, you’ll notice it offers impressive power and horsepower. Many models are equipped with a V6 or V8 engine for your more powerful options.

These engines deliver superior torque and a sportier feel for your luxury midsize vehicle.

Turbo and Supercharger

Several Audi S4 models come equipped with a turbo or a supercharger. A turbo provides enhanced power and performance, while a supercharger allows for smoother and more consistent power delivery.

Your choice between the two will heavily depend on your preferred driving experience.

Manual and Automatic Transmissions

The Audi S4 features both manual and automatic transmission options. The smooth DSG transmission is available in certain models, while others offer the classic appeal of a manual transmission.

It allows you to choose the driving experience that best suits your needs.

Safety Features

Lastly, safety features are crucial in any vehicle, and the Audi S4 does not disappoint. You can feel confident and secure behind the wheel by offering various innovative safety features, such as adaptive cruise control and lane-keeping assistance.

Audi S4 Maintenance and Potential Costs

Replacement Parts

Your Audi S4, particularly the B6 generation, may require the replacement of certain parts during its lifetime. These could include the clutch, control arm, and airbag components. Always opt for genuine Audi replacement parts to ensure optimal performance and longevity.

Service and Repair Costs

As a luxury midsize vehicle, the Audi S4 sits at the higher end of the cost spectrum for service and repair. Yearly maintenance costs average around $1,200.

Remember that this is about twice the repair cost for an average sedan. B6 S4 models specifically can experience a higher frequency of repairs, which may be more severe than other vehicles in the same segment.

Staying aware of potential maintenance costs and risks should help you make an informed decision about purchasing a used Audi S4.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which engine issues affect S4 models?

The Audi S4 is a high-performance vehicle; like any other, it can suffer from engine issues. Some common problems include excessive oil consumption, timing chain issues, and carbon buildup.

Maintenance and regular inspections are vital to keep your S4 running smoothly and to address any potential issues before they become significant problems.

Are certain S4 production years more reliable?

Yes, certain S4 production years are considered to be more reliable than others. For instance, the 2012 and 2013 models are known for reliability and modern performance.

Always thoroughly research and inspect any used vehicle before purchasing, as individual cars can vary in quality and maintenance history.

How do S4 models compare to A4 in reliability?

While the Audi S4 and A4 are luxury sedans, the S4 is more powerful and sporty. Reliability for both models can vary depending on the production year and maintenance history. Check out what Audi A4 years to avoid for used models.

It is essential to weigh your priorities and preferences when choosing between the two models, considering factors like performance, comfort, and overall condition and their reliability.


Chevrolet SSR

These 29 Hyped Cars Failed and Drivers Were Disappointed

Imagine an engine’s roar that ends in a whisper, a sleek design that blends into obscurity, and advanced features that leave us unimpressed. The car industry is where new models aim for the spotlight, yet
Car Thief Car Robbery

20 of the Most Stolen Cars in America (According to Data)

Car theft has almost doubled nationwide since 2017. Not only that, but the thieves are likely getting away with it. For example, only 7% of thefts in Denver (one of the worst-hit cities in the nation) in 2022
Honda, Lexus and Toyota

Mechanics Revealed: 22 Car Brands That Currently Have the Most Reliable Models

Imagine this: you’re cruising down the highway, the smooth hum of the engine is music to your ears, and you’re confident that your car won’t let you down. This isn’t just any car, though –


Sign up now to get the email newsletter and exclusive deals weekly.