Is a Blown Engine Worth Fixing? Should I Get My Engine Replaced or Buy A New Car?

Patrick Oziegbe
Published On:

A blown engine can be a car owner’s worst nightmare, leaving you wondering if it’s worth fixing or if you should just cut your losses.

The decision to repair or replace a blown engine depends on multiple factors, such as the extent of the damage, the age and value of your car, and the overall cost of repairs.

It’s essential to weigh your options carefully before making any decisions.

Understanding the causes of a blown engine and recognizing its symptoms can help you prevent such issues.

Knowing your options when faced with a blown engine can save you time and money. In this article, we’ll explore evaluating whether a blown engine is worth fixing and the alternatives to engine repair.


Key Takeaways

  • Assessing the extent of damage and the costs involved is crucial in deciding whether to fix a blown engine.
  • Understanding the causes and symptoms can help prevent future engine problems.
  • Exploring alternatives to engine repair, such as selling or trading in your car, can save time and money.

Is a Blown Engine Worth Fixing?

Recognizing a Blown Engine

Symptoms of a Blown Engine

Some common signs your engine might be blown include engine overheating, blue or white exhaust smoke, and rattling or knocking noises.

By paying attention to these warning signs, you can take the necessary steps to fix your engine or determine whether it’s worth the repair cost.

Identifying Engine Overheating

Engine overheating indicates something is wrong, and it could be a sign of a blown engine. You might notice your temperature gauge rising or steam coming under the hood.

Various factors, such as a failing water pump, a blocked radiator, or a damaged head gasket, can cause overheating.

If your engine is consistently overheating, it’s crucial to have it checked by a professional mechanic to determine the underlying issue and prevent further damage.

RELATED: Discover what is the engine life of a Sprinter van. And, is a BlueTEC diesel a good engine and reliable?

Spotting Blue or White Exhaust Smoke

Blue or white exhaust smoke is another symptom that might point toward a blown engine. Blue smoke usually indicates oil burning within the engine, which can result from damaged seals or rings.

On the other hand, white exhaust smoke is often caused by coolant leaking into the engine and burning with the fuel.

Both of these issues can lead to significant damage to your engine and should be addressed promptly.

Understanding Rattling or Knocking in the Engine

Rattling or knocking sounds coming from your engine can signal a blown engine. These noises are often caused by engine parts coming into contact with one another, as they should not be in regular operation.

This might result from worn bearings, damaged pistons, or a failed timing chain.

If you hear rattling or knocking in your engine, inspect your vehicle to identify the cause and determine if your engine can be repaired or needs to be replaced.

Understanding Blown Engine Causes

Exploring Engine Failure Reasons

When discussing a blown engine, it generally means that your engine has experienced severe damage and requires rebuilding or replacement. Engine failure can result from various issues, from the mechanical to the environmental.

Effects of Low-Engine Oil

One cause of engine failure is low engine oil. Insufficient oil levels can increase friction, overheating, and damage the engine’s moving parts. It’s essential to monitor your oil levels and change them regularly to avoid such issues.

Impact of Over-Revving

Another cause of the blown engine is over-revving. Pushing your engine to extremely high RPMs can lead to failure in the rotating assembly and ultimately damage the engine block. Being mindful of your engine’s RPMs during driving can help prevent a blown engine situation.

RELATED: Discover how cold is too cold for a diesel engine? Why is V6 Faster than V4? Exploring key differences in engine performance

How Much Can You Get For A Car With A Blown Engine?

If your car has a blown engine, it’s natural to wonder how much you can get for it. The value of a car with a blown engine depends on several factors, such as the make, model, and overall condition.

For example, if your car is worth $9,000 and in good condition, you can earn around $6,000 with a blown engine.

Engine replacement costs for most cars can range between $3,000 and $5,000 on average. Therefore, weighing the costs and benefits of fixing the engine versus selling the car as-is is essential.

Evaluating the Costs of a Blown Engine

Estimating Engine Repair Costs

When your car’s engine is blown, you must assess the damage and the costs involved. Based on factors such as make, model, and mileage, engine repair costs can vastly vary.

However, a simple repair might not be sufficient for a blown engine.

Considering Major Engine Repair Costs

You may need to consider a major engine repair in cases of significant damage. A comprehensive overhaul of the engine can be expensive.

Depending on the severity, it could cost you upwards of $5,000. When evaluating these costs, weigh the expenses against your car’s current value and budget constraints.

Factoring in Replacement Costs

In some situations, a complete engine replacement may be more feasible. Replacement costs depend on whether you opt for a new, used, or remanufactured engine.

While you might think this route is more expensive, it could make your vehicle last longer and save you more in the long run. So, consider exploring and comparing replacement options before making a decision.

Should I Get My Engine Replaced or Buy A New Car?

When faced with a blown engine, it’s natural to wonder if you should replace it or purchase a new car. Consider the costs involved in both scenarios.

Engine replacement typically costs between $2,500 to $6,000, while a new car can be 3 or 4 times more expensive.

Weigh the pros and cons before making a decision. Remanufactured engines sometimes make better sense, especially if your engine is severely worn out or damaged.

Checking the Condition of Your Engine

Performing an Engine Inspection

To determine if your engine is worth fixing:

  1. Start by conducting an engine inspection.
  2. Look for noticeable issues like oil leaks, cracked belts, or loose components.
  3. Consider taking your car to a professional mechanic if you need more time.

Inspecting Internal Engine Components

Next, check the internal engine components. This includes examining the pistons, crankshaft, and camshaft for any signs of damage or excessive wear. Consider using a borescope or having a mechanic evaluate the engine’s internals.

Identifying Combustion Problems

Finally, identify any combustion problems that might indicate a blown engine. This can involve checking the spark plugs, ignition system, and fuel injectors for signs of malfunction.

Additionally, look for any indicators of coolant entering the combustion chamber, as this can lead to a blown engine.

Remember to keep a friendly tone, maintain brevity, highlight key facts, and avoid exaggeration or false claims while discussing the engine, blown engine, inspection, internal engine components, and combustion problems in this section.

Exploring Blown Engine Repair

Understanding Engine Rebuilding

blown engine can be a significant setback, but rebuilding it could be viable. During the engine rebuilding, your mechanic will replace damaged components and restore the engine to working condition.

It can help you save money compared to a complete engine replacement cost.

However, you should consider the extent of damage and the overall repair costs and consult a trusted mechanic to determine if rebuilding is a practical choice for your vehicle.

Contemplating Complete Engine Replacement

In some cases, the blown engine might be beyond repair, and it’s necessary to consider a complete engine replacement.

Replacing the engine can be costly but might be a better long-term investment, especially if your current engine has experienced severe damage.

While this option requires a more significant upfront expense, it may provide more reliable and efficient performance.

Understanding the Mechanic’s Role

Knowing When to Consult a Mechanic

A blown engine can be a severe issue requiring consulting a mechanic. If you notice problems such as oil and coolant leaks, combustion issues, or engine overheating, it’s time to seek professional help.

Deciding Between Mechanic and Do-it-Yourself Fixes

Fixing a blown engine can involve rebuilding or replacing parts. While some may attempt DIY fixes, major issues usually require a skilled mechanic. Weigh the costs and your skill level before making a decision.

Alternatives to Engine Repair

Assessing Engine Selling Options

If your car has a blown engine, consider selling it instead of repairing it. Popular car brands like Audi, BMW, and Honda CR-V often have a decent resale value.

Evaluate the worth of your car with the damaged engine and compare it to the repair cost. This may help you decide whether fixing the engine or selling the car is economical.

Exploring the Value of a Junk Car

Another option is to sell your car as junk, especially if the repair costs are too high. You can still get some money from selling it for parts or scrap.

Taking this route is more financially reasonable than investing in fixing the blown engine.

Preventing Engine Troubles

Maintaining Proper Maintenance

Your vehicle’s engine requires proper maintenance to avoid troubles such as a blown engine. Regularly inspecting your vehicle’s brakes, suspension, steering, and tires is essential.

Addressing any issues with these components can prevent additional stress on your engine and keep it running smoothly.

Recognizing the Importance of Regular Oil Changes

Regular oil changes play a vital role in preventing engine troubles. Fresh oil and a clean filter ensure your engine’s moving parts are lubricated, preventing friction and heat buildup.

Additionally, routinely checking your engine’s oil levels and using the correct grade can further minimize the risk of a blown engine.

Knowing the Role of Timing Belts and Chains

A broken timing belt or chain can cause significant damage to your engine. Replacing these components according to the manufacturer’s recommended schedule is crucial in preventing a blown engine.

Proper timing belt and chain maintenance helps synchronize your engine’s internal components, avoiding severe damage and the cost of an engine rebuild or replacement.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does fixing a blown engine cost?

Fixing a blown engine can be pretty expensive, with costs ranging from a few thousand dollars to over $10,000, depending on the extent of the damage and the make and model of your vehicle. Getting a few quotes from different repair shops is always a good idea to understand the costs involved.

Can a car with a blown engine be repaired?

Yes, a car with a blown engine can be repaired, although it often involves rebuilding or replacing the engine. This process can be time-consuming and expensive, but returning your car to life is possible if you invest in the repairs.

Does a new engine increase a car’s value?

While a new engine can improve your car’s performance, it doesn’t necessarily increase its resale value. A car with a replaced engine may be worth less, as buyers may be concerned about the quality of the repair or the car’s overall reliability.

What should be replaced along with the engine?

When replacing a blown engine, replacing additional components like the water pump, oil pump, timing belt or chain, and transmission is also a good idea. This can help ensure that your vehicle runs smoothly after the repair.

Will dealerships buy cars with blown engines?

Some dealerships may be willing to buy cars with blown engines, but they typically offer a significantly lower price than a car in good running condition. However, selling your car privately or to a junkyard might provide a better return.

Is engine replacement covered under warranty?

Engine replacement might be covered under warranty, but it depends on the specific terms of your vehicle’s warranty. In general, manufacturers’ warranties may cover engine failure due to defects in materials or workmanship.

It’s essential to check your warranty documentation and contact the dealership or manufacturer to determine if your engine replacement is covered.


Honda S2000

33 Marvelous Cars that Surprisingly Let Everyone Down

Picture a world where every car is iconic. But back in reality, many models fail and vanish after one generation, leaving behind a legacy of what could have been. We’re spotlighting 33 such cars that
Maserati GranTurismo

22 Cars Crafted for the Wealthy, Yet Despised by the Public

For the wealthy, a luxury car isn’t simply transportation; it’s an engineering masterpiece and a symbol of elite status. From the $28 million Rolls-Royce Boat Tail to the formidable $2.8 million Koenigsegg Jesko, these cars
Turbo Engine

These are the Top 21 Toyota Engines of All Time

Discover the power and reliability at the core of Toyota’s engineering excellence. These engines are more than just machinery; they’re icons of innovation. With decades of superior performance, Toyota engines are benchmarks in the automotive


Sign up now to get the email newsletter and exclusive deals weekly.