Steer Clear: The 15 Unreliable Pickup Trucks You Should Avoid

Patrick Oziegbe
Published On:

When you think of pickup trucks, durability and reliability often come to mind. However, not all pickup trucks live up to these expectations.

As a truck enthusiast, you should be aware of the most unreliable pickup trucks designed to reach at least 250,000 miles as shown here by Iseecars study.

Throughout the years, there have been numerous models that have experienced problems affecting their overall performance and reliability. Some have earned a notorious reputation for being plagued with issues, while others are simply underwhelming compared to their competitors.

By understanding the common pitfalls of these trucks, you will be better equipped to choose a trustworthy and dependable vehicle.

Key Takeaways

  • Some pickup trucks fall short of their expected reliability and performance.
  • Be informed about problematic models before making a purchase.
  • Understand common issues to make better decisions when choosing a new truck.

Understanding Pickup Truck Reliability

Pickup Truck Reliability
©Photo Credit: MiramarSpeedCircuit

When you’re considering a pickup truck, reliability is an essential factor. A reliable truck ensures fewer issues, longer-lasting quality, and peace of mind. To gauge reliability, sources like Consumer Reports and J.D. Power provide invaluable insights through their reliability ratings.

Your ideal truck should be dependable, exemplifying quality engineering and build. And remember, reliable doesn’t mean boring or without flair.

2017 GMC Sierra 1500

2017 GMC Sierra 1500
©Photo Credit: MiramarSpeedCircuit

The 2017 GMC Sierra 1500 is a well-known pickup truck in the USA. Unfortunately, it faced some issues that you should be aware of.

One of the main concerns is related to braking problems which can affect its reliability. Additionally, airbag issues were reported, leading to two similar recalls to fix the problem.

While the Sierra is built for off-roading, there were particular issues with the transfer case in the 2007 and 2012 models, which may leave you stuck in the mud.

2015 Dodge Ram 2500 (Cummins Diesel Engine)

2015 Dodge Ram 2500
©Photo Credit: MiramarSpeedCircuit

The 2015 Dodge Ram 2500 with a Cummins diesel engine has been listed among the 15 most unreliable pickup trucks.

Although this truck has many strong features, it received a reliability rating of only 11 out of 100. Some of the common issues reported by owners include suspension problems and transmission vibrations.

2006, 2011 Ford F-250 Super Duty

2006, 2011 Ford F-250 Super Duty
©Photo Credit: MiramarSpeedCircuit

The 2006 and 2011 Ford F-250 Super Duty trucks have a history of reliability issues. In 2006, the F-250 was considered one of the worst overall trucks for that year. As a truck owner, you’d want to be cautious when considering these options.

Some common problems with these models include faulty EGR valves, transmission issues, and engine failures. If you’re in the market for a used truck, it’s a good idea to avoid the 2006 and 2011 Ford F-250 Super Duty trucks due to their track record of costly issues.

2005 Ford Explorer Sport Trac

2005 Ford Explorer Sport Trac
©Photo Credit: MiramarSpeedCircuit

The 2005 Ford Explorer Sport Trac is a unique vehicle, blending the characteristics of a pickup truck and an SUV. However, there are some concerns you should know about before considering it for your next truck.

The Sport Trac has a roomy, versatile cabin, with well-rounded performance. Despite its utility, the ride can be stiff and choppy.

2012 Suzuki Equator

2012 Suzuki Equator
©Photo Credit: MiramarSpeedCircuit

Introduced in 2008, the Suzuki Equator had a short-lived presence in the American market until 2012. Based on the Nissan Frontier, it offered a capable V6 engine with decent performance. However, it also faced several reliability issues during its time on the road.

While the Equator’s borrowed components from the Nissan Frontier did provide some relief for buyers seeking replacement parts, it wasn’t enough to save the truck’s reputation. Overall, the truck’s departure from the market left many buyers in a challenging situation with a less-than-reliable vehicle.

1998-2006 Mazda B-Series

1998-2006 Mazda B-Series
©Photo Credit: MiramarSpeedCircuit

During this period, the Mazda B-Series faced some reliability issues which made it one of the most unreliable pickup trucks in the USA. The models from 1998-2006 come in both 2WD and 4WD versions.

A major problem was its lack of durability, resulting in mechanical failures and a shortened lifespan. It’s important for you to be aware of the reputation these trucks have garnered so that you can make informed decisions when choosing a pickup.

2002 Lincoln Blackwood

2002 Lincoln Blackwood
©Photo Credit: MiramarSpeedCircuit

You might be surprised to learn that the 2002 Lincoln Blackwood happens to be one of the most unreliable pickup trucks. It stood out with its unique design, but faced reliability issues.

Weighing 5637 pounds, this luxury pickup was equipped with a 5.4-liter DOHC 32-valve V-8 engine. However, the Blackwood’s distinctive features didn’t make up for its performance and reliability shortcomings.

2019 Mercedes-Benz X-Class

2019 Mercedes-Benz X-Class
©Photo Credit: MiramarSpeedCircuit

The 2019 Mercedes-Benz X-Class is indeed a luxury pickup truck, but don’t let its appearance fool you. With a Nissan Navara base, it may not provide the reliability you seek.

It offers 4MATIC all-wheel drive and a 2,298cc I4 diesel engine that produces 140kW at 3,750 rpm and 450Nm. However, always consider true reliability ratings when browsing for your perfect pickup.

2000-2003 Ram 1500

2000-2003 Ram 1500
©Photo Credit: MiramarSpeedCircuit

During this period, the Ram 1500 faced some reliability issue. Among these years, 2003 was particularly troublesome for the truck. There were reports of problems with the 5.7-liter V8 engine, leading to recalls.

In general, it’s suggested that you:

  • Be cautious with these model years
  • Research individual trucks thoroughly
  • Consider newer models for improved reliability.

2021 Ford F-150 Hybrid

2021 Ford F-150 Hybrid
©Photo Credit: MiramarSpeedCircuit

The 2021 Ford F-150 PowerBoost Hybrid has been reported to be unreliable due to a variety of issues. Generally, this model reported very low reliability score, owners have cited numerous problem areas.

Specific concerns mentioned include the potential for a faulty Hybrid Drive Unit or Battery, or issues with a harness or connector in the High Voltage system as indicated in discussions on F150gen14 forum.

Additionally, there have been mentions of battery problems but not directly related to the battery pack for the PowerBoost system, and some reports of coolant leak related problems.

2022 Chevrolet Silverado

2022 Chevrolet Silverado
©Photo Credit: MiramarSpeedCircuit

The 2022 Chevrolet Silverado is known to have some reliability issues. Despite their popularity and strength in towing, there are a few areas where owners have reported problems.

These include the truck’s engines, paint, leaks, noises, electrical systems, and brakes. Keep in mind, though, that thousands of people still buy and enjoy these trucks every year.

It’s worth being aware of these issues while still appreciating the Silverado’s powerful performance and long-standing heritage. Just approach with caution and do your research on individual models before making a decision.

2001 Toyota Tundra

2001 Toyota Tundra
©Photo Credit: MiramarSpeedCircuit

The 2001 Toyota Tundra had some reliability issues, ranking only 52 out of 100. Despite this, certain aspects have been praised, such as the 2000 Tundra model’s long-lasting nature.

To provide you with a glimpse, here are some pros and cons of the 2001 Tundra:

  • Exhaust leaks due to rust on the exhaust system
  • Not the most reliable model within the lineup.

2008 Chevrolet Colorado

2008 Chevrolet Colorado
©Photo Credit: MiramarSpeedCircuit

The 2008 Chevrolet Colorado has a rugged exterior design, making it visually appealing. Unfortunately, its reliability doesn’t hold up as well. When considering pickup trucks, you’ll want to be aware of the Colorado’s shortcomings.

The sparse cabin, for example, leaves room for improvement. Fuel efficiency is not this truck’s best feature either, with i5 models averaging 15/20 miles to the gallon.

2006 Honda Ridgeline

2006 Honda Ridgeline
©Photo Credit: MiramarSpeedCircuit

While the Honda Ridgeline is typically known for reliability, the 2006 model year faced some issues. As a new release, it had minor bugs to iron out.

Its 3.5-liter V-6 engine produced 255 horsepower and 252 pound-feet of torque, but performance and consumer satisfaction were impacted by these kinks.

Don’t let this deter you, as later Ridgeline models have improved significantly. Just remember, when shopping for a used pickup truck, it’s best to avoid the 2006 Honda Ridgeline.

2004-5 Nissan Titan

2004-5 Nissan Titan
©Photo Credit: MiramarSpeedCircuit

The 2004-5 Nissan Titan had some issues during its first generation. These trucks are part of a list called Nissan Titan years to avoid. Although reliable, they faced common problems:

  • Brake system issues: Sticking brake calipers, worn brake pads, and brake judder.
  • Exhaust leaks: Leaks in the exhaust manifold might occur, causing a sulfur smell.
  • Transmission problems: Some Titans experienced hard shifting and transmission failure.

Common Issues in Unreliable Trucks

Common Issues
©Photo Credit: MiramarSpeedCircuit

Transmission Problems

Some trucks, like the Chevy Silverado and GMC Sierra, have issues with their transmission systems. This can lead to poor gear shifts, slipping clutches, and even complete transmission failure.

Engine and Powertrain Flaws

Certain engines may suffer from excessive oil consumption or overall lack of power. The 2018 Ford F-150, for instance, has a malfunctioning transfer case, affecting the power delivery to the wheels.

Braking System Deficiencies

Some trucks may experience brake fluid loss or weak braking systems. The same 2018 Ford F-150 also suffers from issues like these, making it less reliable in emergency situations.

Electrical and In-Car Electronics Issues

A common issue in unreliable trucks is faulty electrical equipment. The Chevy Silverado and GMC Sierra are known for in-car electronics problems, such as failing infotainment systems or malfunctioning sensors.

Fuel Economy and Emission Faults

Lastly, poor fuel economy and emission faults can negatively impact the reputation of a truck. Inefficient engines or emission system faults may lead to reduced performance and increased expenses for you, especially with rising fuel costs.

Advancements in Reliable Pickup Truck Technology

Advancements in Reliable Pickup Truck Technology
©Photo Credit: MiramarSpeedCircuit

Innovations in Ford Pickup Trucks

Ford has made significant advancements in recent years, such as the Ford F-150 Hybrid and the Ford Maverick, which combine fuel efficiency with cutting-edge technology to make your life easier.

Developments Beyond Traditional Trucks

Alternative truck options like the Honda Ridgeline and the Ford Explorer Sport Trac blur the lines between pickups and SUVs. They provide utility while maintaining the comfort of a full-size vehicle.

The Rise of Alternative Fuel Options

Today’s market sees an increasing number of alternative fuel options. For example, the Ford F-150 Hybrid offers fuel efficiency without sacrificing performance.

Notable Discontinued Models

Although iconic trucks like the Lincoln Blackwood, Chevrolet Avalanche, and Dodge Ram 2500/3500 have unfortunately been discontinued, they served as important stepping stones to where we are now.

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

what does the 1500 mean on a truck

What Does the 1500 Mean on a Truck?

If you’re in the market for a powerhouse pickup, you may ask yourself “What does the 1500 mean on a truck?” In your quest to understand this number, you will find that there are other
4 door pickup trucks

4 Door Pickup Trucks: What To Know Before You Buy

Nothing beats a pickup truck when it comes to practicality and versatility. It can serve you well whether you’re moving, transporting bulky items like furniture, camping, tailgating, or road-tripping. These days, 4 door pickup trucks
Comparing Ford F250 vs F350 Insurance Cost

Differences Between Heavy Duty F250 vs F350 Insurance Cost

If you’re currently deciding between purchasing a F250 vs F350 insurance, it makes sense to shop around for car insurance when considering overall costs. Thankfully, the likelihood of your insurance costs as much as a

SUBSCRIBE TODAY

Sign up now to get the email newsletter and exclusive deals weekly.